Topic, 5 Point System to: Reject / Edit / Accept / Earn a Slide / Official

  oh_bebe LOL! (the end)

  I agree with Ninja about the voting for official levels.. Some people vote for levels to be official that I don't even think should have been accepted!! :P

And I also agree with him that the standards of accepting levels should be higher now. (For one example, a level that I would have once told someone to make a lot neater, plus other suggestions I will just reject. Because most of the time it gets edited and is not any better.)

  That was a suggestion XD

  Not everyone knows what levels are good enough to be official, and vote for levels that are not qualified...
And a certain difficulty should definently not add a point.
I still think the first system is the best.

  What about
1 pt. Neat
1 pt. Detailed
1 pt. Fun
1 pt. Original
1 pt. Good lenght
1 pt. At least 5 votes for official
1 pt. At least 10 votes for official
1 pt. Hard

0, 1, 2 - Reject
3, 4 - Edit
5 - Accept
6 - Accept / Possibly Earn a Slide / Possibly Official
7 - Official
8 - Official / Possibly on the homepage

  What About:
0-12: Reject
13-18: Edit
19-24: Accept
25: Accept/Slide/Official

  oh_bebe and I just think that we need to raise our standards here at BL. Too many poor levels are getting accepted nowadays.

  or it could be editable :-)

  And if a level is very neat and very original, but not detailed, fun, and has a bad length , then it should not be rejected.

  It's a nice idea. But this must stay a helping system, because it will not work on every situation.
For example a level can be 4/5, but there is a small thing to correct (like not enough checkpoints, or a problem with a checkpoint and paths). In this case you will use "to edit" before accepting it. But the rating will help you to decide I agree.

Don't forget that only admins can comment on unaccepted levels. If you want to request the help of all members on a level, you have to make the first post on this level.

  Was that supposed to be funny?

Anyway, that's a good idea!

  Its a Neat idea!

  what a good idea , but the most levels i get aren't messy xp so i almost accept evry level.

  Yeah...but Admin is more serious then most of the players in BL...you know...xP

  that is also a good way to rate levels!

  Good point, but is is a bit more effective, if they have notepad handy...!

  why not just have 1 point each and keep it very simple?
it is just for the admins to use in their head anyway, not to actually rate online

  What about mine?

  i like Oh_bebe's idea...xD

  I think it's good, but what about out of 5 and scores mean:
0-10 Reject
11-15 Edit
16-23 Accept
24 or 25 Accept/Slide/Official

  Here is an idea to help admins decide how to evaluate a level when they cannot decide between Reject / Edit / Accept.

This is a 5 Point System:

1 pt. Neat
1 pt. Detailed
1 pt. Fun
1 pt. Original
1 pt. Good length

2/5 or less = Reject
3/5 = Edit
4/5 = Accept
5/5 = Accept / Possibly Earn a Slide / Possibly Official

This system could be just used mentally by the admins.. I don't think it needs to be on the website. Just thought maybe it would help for those in-between kind of levels.